Hold vs Sell — Property Modelling
Last updated 2026-05-03
What it does
For each investment property, Frank models two paths over the same horizon:
- Hold — projected value (capital growth) + cumulative rent − cumulative cash drag − remaining mortgage at the end
- Sell now and reinvest — net cash today (after CGT) compounded at your assumed reinvestment return
Then it shows the delta and which path comes out ahead.
Inputs
- Horizon (years) — default 10
- Capital growth % — annual property growth, default 6
- Rental growth % — annual rent growth, default 3.5
- Reinvest return % — what you'd earn on the sale proceeds, default 7
- Sale price today — override the asset's current value with a specific sale price
- Other taxable income — for CGT marginal rate, default $135k
Outputs
Hold side:
- Projected end value
- Remaining mortgage
- Cumulative cash drag (interest + costs − rent − tax shields)
- Net position
Sell side:
- Net cash today (after CGT, with 50% discount applied if held >12 months)
- CGT payable
- Reinvested value at the horizon
Comparison:
- Delta + direction (hold ahead by X / sell ahead by X)
- Percentage delta vs the sell scenario
Information only
Frank doesn't tell you to hold or sell. The model has a lot of moving parts (growth assumptions, tax position at sale, reinvestment vehicle, transaction costs not fully captured). Use it as a starting point for the conversation with your accountant or planner.
Was this article helpful?
Related Articles
Running Financial Scenarios
Use the Plan page to model financial decisions before you make them — property purchases, debt strategies, and more.
Salary Packaging Optimiser
Side-by-side current vs optimised pay breakdown. Sliders for extra salary sacrifice, novated lease, ECM, and bonus deferred to super. Concessional cap headroom check baked in.
Refinance Modelling
Model your current loan vs a candidate refinance. Compare monthly payment, total interest, and break-even payback period after switching costs.